Utilisation peropératoire des signes de la marche d’escalier corticale et de la différence de diamètre : précision, accord inter-observateurs et influence du niveau d’expérience chirurgicale dans les fractures transverses sous-trochantériennes - 19/06/20
Intraoperative use of cortical step sign and diameter difference sign: Accuracy, inter-rater agreement and influence of surgical experience in subtrochanteric transverse fractures
, Eduardo Suero a, Miriam Bogusch a, Carl Neuerburg a, Kirsi Marjaana Manz b, Christopher A. Becker a, Nima Befrui a, Christian Kammerlander a, Wolfgang Böcker a, Christian Zeckey aAbstract |
Background |
The cortical step sign (CSS) and diameter difference sign (DDS) are radiographic tools for torsional alignment control in intramedullary nailing. They have been found to be highly relevant in objective radiographic measurements, but for intraoperative visual identification they lack sufficient evidence yet. The aim of this experimental study was to evaluate their: (1) accuracy; (2) inter-rater agreement; (3) predictors of correct identification for clinically relevant maltorsion (CRM: ≥15°); and (4) positive and negative predictive values.
Hypothesis |
Sensitivity and specificitiy of CSS and DDS in visual identification of CRM are comparable to those in objective measurement.
Material and methods |
Six observers of three different levels of surgical experience evaluated 50a.p. and 50 lateral views of subtrochanteric fractures of cadaveric specimens with internal/external maltorsion from 0° to 30° to assess for CSS, DDS, and CRM. (1) Sensitivity and specificity were evaluated. Percentage agreement and Cohen's Kappa were used to evaluate accuracy as agreement with measured/true values and (2) inter-rater agreement. To determine (3) significant predictors of correct identification of the CSS, DDS, and CRM, a mixed-effects logistic model was constructed, and (4) predictive values were calculated.
Results |
(1) Sensitivities of CSS and DDS for CRM (0.99±0.03 and 0.88±0.06) were close to those in objective measurement (1.00 and 0.90). So were specificities (0.25±0.08 and 0.47±0.17 vs. 0.32 and 0.47). Agreement percentage for CSS was high (90–94%, kappa 0.40–0.69), for DDS and CRM it was slightly lower (74–82%, kappa 0.34–0.57 and 62–76%, kappa 0.26–0.49). (2) Inter-rater agreement also showed the highest values for CSS (88–96%, kappa 0.51–0.73) with slightly lower values for DDS (74–84%, kappa 0.36–0.63) and CRM (62–84%, kappa 0.21–0.68). (3) Training level and the magnitude of maltorsion were found the most relevant predictors of a correct identification of CSS/DDS/CRM. (4) DDS showed a higher positive predictive value (73.1%), CSS a higher negative predictive value (93.5%).
Discussion |
We found visual identification of CSS and DDS to be almost as accurate as objective measurement in the detection of CRM. Estimation of maltorsion is not sufficiently reliable, but a negative CSS excludes a CRM with high probability. Both signs should be applied by experienced surgeons.
Level of evidence |
III, experimental setting, non-randomised experimental trial.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Keywords : Bone malalignment, Intramedullary nailing, Femoral fractures, Hip fractures, Torsion abnormality
| ☆ | Cet article peut être consulté in extenso dans la version anglaise de la revue Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research sur Science Direct (sciencedirect.com) en utilisant le DOI ci-dessus. |
Vol 106 - N° 4
P. 365 - juin 2020 Retour au numéro
Article précédent
- Fractures Pertrochantériennes et « Fast Track » : quels impacts fonctionnels et d’autonomie après hospitalisation ?
- Mathurin Gomez, Louis Rony, Clément Marc, Abdelhafid Talha, Nicolas Ruiz, Sophie Noublanche, André Gillibert, Sara Bergman, Vincent Maynard, Laurent Hubert
- Prothèse totale de hanche après échecs d’ostéosynthèse pour fractures du massif trochantérien avec utilisation exclusive de cupules à double-mobilité
- Henri Favreau, Matthieu Ehlinger, Philippe Adam, François Bonnomet
Bienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
L’accès au texte intégral de cet article nécessite un abonnement.
Déjà abonné à cette revue ?