International Multidisciplinary Expert Consensus on the Definition, Diagnosis, and Clinical Relevance of Microscopic and Asymptomatic Endometriosis (MAE): The A-DELPHI Study - 16/11/26
, Sun-Wei Guo b, Harald Krentel c, Kutay Biberoglu d, Sara Maki b, Ahmed Elminawi e, Ainur Tuletova f, Angela G. Sison-Aguilar g, Yoke-Fai Fong h, Alexander Popov i, Amr El-Shalakany j, Antonio Privitera b, Natalia V. Artymuk k, Cecilia Hoi Man Ng l, Engin Oral m, Felice Petraglia n, Gamal I. Serour o, Hemantha Senanayake p, Islam Magalov q, Luay Abu Atileh r, Michael Cooper s, Michel Canis t, Mohamed Bedaiwy u, Mukhri Hamdan v, Viganò Paola w, Saeed Alborzi x, Sameena Chowdhury y, Shamsa Al Awar b, Taner Usta z, Tasuku Harada aa, Vitaly Bezhenar ab, Yutaka Osuga ac, Yuval Kaufman adOn behalf of the A-DELPHI Steering Committee and International Expert Panel on Microscopic and Asymptomatic Endometriosis
Highlights |
• | International experts agreed on standardised terminology. |
• | Routine invasive investigation for asymptomatic disease was discouraged. |
• | Microscopic disease alone should not prompt additional surgery. |
• | Fertility management should be individualised. |
• | Important diagnostic and treatment uncertainties remain. |
Abstract |
Objective |
To develop international multidisciplinary consensus on the definition, diagnosis, clinical relevance, management, and research priorities of microscopic and asymptomatic endometriosis.
Material and methods: An international two-round modified Delphi study was conducted from March to June 2026. Fifty experts were purposively invited based on their research, clinical, professional leadership, or guideline-development experience. Thirty-one experts from 22 countries completed both rounds. Round 1 responses underwent descriptive and thematic analysis and informed 21 statements rated in Round 2 using a nine-point Likert scale. Consensus was defined a priori as at least 70% agreement and less than 15% disagreement.
Results |
Consensus was reached for 16 of 21 statements (76.2%). All experts supported standardized terminology and individualized fertility management. Twenty-nine of 31 experts (93.5%) agreed that asymptomatic endometriosis should not routinely be sought through invasive investigation and that microscopic disease should not prompt surgery without another clinical indication. Twenty-eight experts (90.3%) supported recognising microscopic endometriosis as a distinct pathological entity. Consensus was not reached on minimum histopathological criteria, the contribution of microscopic disease to pain or infertility, infertility alone as evidence of clinically significant disease, or routine treatment of incidentally diagnosed asymptomatic endometriosis.
Conclusion |
The panel supported standardized terminology, avoidance of routine invasive investigation, and individualized management. Persistent uncertainty regarding diagnostic thresholds, clinical significance, and treatment requires prospective longitudinal research using patient-relevant outcomes.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Keywords : endometriosis, microscopic endometriosis, asymptomatic endometriosis, Delphi technique, diagnostic criteria, clinical management
Plan
Bienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
