Menstrual health inequities and the health capability paradigm: an ethical framework for policy reform in India - 18/11/26
Highlights |
• | Menstrual health inequities in India constitute a preventable structural injustice |
• | A decade of MHHM schemes fail due to health agency, conversion, and governance gaps |
• | Health Capability Paradigm uniquely integrates functioning, agency, and governance |
• | HCP outperforms Sen, Nussbaum, Venkatapuram, and Daniels for MHHM policy reform |
• | Four HCP-grounded policy recommendations address India's menstrual health deficit |
Abstract |
Background |
Poor Menstrual Health and Hygiene Management (MHHM) creates preventable health inequities among women and girls in India. Despite over a decade of government initiatives, significant inequalities in menstrual health outcomes persist across region, residence, wealth, caste, and disability. This paper argues that the persistent gaps are not primarily a failure of resources or political will, but of theoretical framework: initiatives have been designed without an adequate ethical foundation that integrates material provision, health agency, structural conversion conditions, and institutional governance.
Methodology |
This is a normative and analytical study. The Health Capability Paradigm (HCP), developed by Jennifer Prah Ruger, is applied as a theoretical lens to critically examine Indian MHHM policy. Government schemes were identified through government records, official survey data, and published secondary literature. Competing theories of health justice, such as, including Sen's and Nussbaum's capability approaches, Venkatapuram's meta-capability framework, and Daniels' Rawlsian account are evaluated through comparative philosophical analysis. No formal systematic review methodology was undertaken.
Results/Discussion |
The MHHM schemes analysed in this study share a consistent three-dimensional policy deficit: they address material resource provision while neglecting health agency, failing to engage the specific mechanisms through which menstrual stigma functions as a structural conversion barrier, and lacking shared governance mechanisms with capability-based accountability. The HCP is argued to be a particularly useful policy framework for integrating the dimensions, such as, material resources, health functioning, health agency, social conversion conditions, and institutional governance in case of menstrual health promotion, that alternative frameworks do not combine with equivalent analytical specificity.
Conclusion/Perspectives |
The HCP provides a well-grounded and relatively practically applicable ethical framework for addressing menstrual health inequities in India. Four HCP-grounded policy recommendations are proposed for policy reform. The central prescription is that MHHM policy must reconceive menstrual health inequity not as a resource problem alone, but as a capability problem, attending to whether material provision is accompanied by the structural conditions that enable individuals to convert resources into genuine health outcomes.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Keywords : Health capability paradigm, Health justice, India, Menstrual health, Menstrual Health and Hygiene Management (MHHM), Menstrual stigma, Structural injustice
Plan
Vol 34
Article 101360- 2026 Retour au numéroBienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
L’accès au texte intégral de cet article nécessite un abonnement.
Déjà abonné à cette revue ?

