Lower-limb valgus deformity exceeding 20° is a particular case, with few publications assessing the impact of the severity of the valgus. The present retrospective case control study compared a series of>20° valgus versus a series of 10–20° valgus, assessing (1) operative data [approach, type of total knee replacement (TKR)], (2) complications and implant survival, and (3) clinical and radiological results.

Severe valgus deformity requires TKR with greater constraint, incurring a higher rate of complications and poorer implant survival.

A multicenter retrospective study for the period January 2006 to December 2010 included 53 patients, with a mean age of 72±10 years, presenting>20° valgus. The study series was matched for age and gender with a series of 53 cases of 10–20° valgus. Convexity laxity was greater in the>20° group (p=0.004).

There was no significant inter-group difference in approach (p=0.13). Greater constraint was more frequent in the>20° group (7/53 versus 1/53; p=0.03), independently of convexity laxity or Krackow grade (p=0.14). There were 7 complications (13.2%) in the>20° group and 7 in the 10–20° group (NS). Eight-year survivorship was 95.12% in the>20° group and 94.9% in the 10–20° group (p=0.63). There were no significant differences in Oxford score (p=0.30) or HKA angle (p=0.78) at last follow-up.

The study hypothesis was partially confirmed: greater constraint was more frequent in>20° valgus. The number of complications was low, and survival was identical to that of a control group with less severe deformity.

III, retrospectivecase controlstudy.