Cardiogenic shock from acute on chronic heart failure is a lethal condition that frequently requires temporary mechanical circulatory support devices (tMCS) as a bridge to stabilization, durable support, or heart transplantation. However, there are limited data on methods to optimize use of tMCS in this population. We identified patients who received tMCS devices for cardiogenic shock from acute on chronic heart failure at a single center from August 2016 to July 2020. All the patients had invasive hemodynamic data before and immediately after tMCS placement. We classified patients according to whether they showed stabilization or decompensation with tMCS. We then evaluated hemodynamics pre-tMCS, post-tMCS, and the change in hemodynamics with tMCS (∆-tMCS) and assessed their relationship with clinical outcomes. Among 111 patients who received tMCS, 71 stabilized, and 40 decompensated. Post-tMCS hemodynamics were more likely than were pre-tMCS or ∆-tMCS to predict stabilization. Post-tMCS cardiac index >2.1 (area under the curve: 92.2) and cardiac power index >0.3 (area under the curve: 89.6) were the best predictors of stabilization. Patients who decompensated had increased in-hospital all-cause mortality (hazard ratio 3.06 [1.29 to 7.24], p = 0.011), cardiovascular mortality, and increased hospital and intensive care unit length of stay and were less likely to receive left ventricular assist device or heart transplant (hazard ratio 0.56 [0.36 to 0.88], p = 0.01). In conclusion, among patients with cardiogenic shock from acute on chronic heart failure who received tMCS, post-tMCS cardiac index and cardiac power index were highly predictive of stabilization. Those who decompensated had increased mortality, hospital length of stay, and intensive care unit length of stay and were less likely to receive heart replacement therapy.