Metatarsal fractures are the most common type of foot fracture. When surgical treatment is needed, pinning is typically used, either percutaneous or open. However, this fixation method has been criticized by some authors who lament residual malunion and prefer to use plate and/or screws. The primary objective of our study was to compare the outcomes of K-wire versus plate and/or screw fixation for the surgical treatment of two or more metatarsal fractures. The secondary objective was to evaluate the factors that contribute to poor outcomes and complications. We hypothesized that plate and/or screw fixation will produce better functional outcomes than K-wire fixation.

This was a prospective and retrospective multicenter study carried out between 1 January 2010 and 1 June 2018 with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. Three functional scores were determined (AOFAS, FAAM and SF12 physical and mental) preoperatively, postoperatively and at the final assessment. We evaluated the outcomes in the entire study population and in four injury type subgroups, including one with isolated metatarsal fractures to control analysis bias.

Our analysis compiled data from 165 patients (123 men, 42 women) who had a mean age of 38 years (16–82). The mean follow-up time was 27.9months (10–120). There were no complications in 130 patients (79%). Skin necrosis occurred in 25 patients (15%). The FAAM score was significantly higher in the plate and/or screw group 70.2 (17-84) versus 60.3 (31-84) in the K-wire group (P=0.033). The 78 (19–100) AOFAS was higher, but not significantly, in the plate and/or screw group versus 70 (12–100) in the K-wire group (P=0.144).

Trauma to the foot that causes a fracture in two or more metatarsals often occurs due to a crush injury (39%). The frequency of associated bone lesions means that a preoperative CT scan should be done routinely to analyze the injury pattern and determine the best treatment. The fixation method should be adapted to the local conditions; when possible, it is preferable to use rigid fixation with plates and/or screws as it yields better functional outcomes.

IV; study with retrospective component.