A comparison of UK and French guidelines on the identification of pregnant women at low-risk of complications: a nationwide population-based study - 21/11/26
, Alice Hocquette 1, Marie Viaud 1, Nathalie Lelong 1, Béatrice Blondel 1, Camille Le Ray 1, 2, Isabelle Monier 1Enp2021 Study Group
Abstract |
Objective |
To compare UK and French guidelines on the identification of pregnant women at low-risk of complications
Design |
National population-based study
Setting |
All births in France over 1 week in 2021
Population |
11,845 women with a live-born singleton, with data abstracted from medical records and maternal interviews
Main Outcome Measures |
Prevalence of low-risk women and discrepancies in low-risk exclusion criteria between UK and French guidelines
Results |
The prevalence of women at low-risk was 64.2% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 63.3-65.0) and 71.2% (70.4-72.0) according to UK and French guidelines, respectively. Overall, 58.9% (58.0-59.8) of women were at low-risk according to both guidelines, 5.2% (4.8-5.6) according to UK guidelines only and 12.3% (11.7-12.9) for French guidelines only. Risk level is assessed at the beginning of pregnancy in French guidelines but at the end of pregnancy in UK guidelines. Uterine scar and insulin-treated gestational diabetes were the main low-risk exclusion criteria in UK but not French guidelines. A history of a small-for-gestational age (SGA) newborn or preterm birth and antenatal suspicion of SGA for the current pregnancy were the main low-risk exclusion criteria in French but not UK guidelines.
Conclusions |
The prevalence of pregnant women at low-risk of complications differed between UK and French guidelines because of discrepancies in the timing of risk assessment and low-risk exclusion criteria. This suggests the need for complementary guidelines including criteria derived from validation studies to orient low-risk women toward both the appropriate practitioner for prenatal follow-up and the suitable place of birth.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Keywords : low-risk, guidelines, criteria, prenatal care, delivery, birth place
Plan
Bienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
L’accès au texte intégral de cet article nécessite un abonnement.
Déjà abonné à cette revue ?
