Benefits and risks of hot water immersion for venomous fish stings: a case of iatrogenic burn after an envenomation consistent with stonefish - 21/11/26
, Sébastien Larréché 3, 4, 5, Fanny Andry 6, Alizé Mercier 7, Gaël Le Roux 1, 2Abstract |
Background: Hot water immersion (HWI) is widely recommended as first-line treatment for painful venomous fish stings, on the principle that protein-based venoms are heat-inactivated. This rationale rests on experiments conducted on venom in solution and has never been validated in patients. Guidelines also differ on water temperature and immersion duration.
Methods: We describe a woman treated with HWI in an emergency department on Reunion Island for an envenomation consistent with stonefish, using the clinical record and sequential photographs. We combined this case with a species-by-species appraisal of published evidence on the heat sensitivity of venomous bony fish venoms and the clinical efficacy of HWI.
Principal findings: The patient developed a second-degree thermal burn, with blisters appearing 6 to 24 hours after immersion over the area of water contact rather than at the puncture site. No study demonstrates venom inactivation by HWI in patients. Recommended temperatures range from 42 to 50 °C and durations from 20 to 90 minutes, without regard to species, whereas measured heat sensitivity varies between species. For stonefish, thermolability has been measured in a single species ( Synanceia horrida ), in free solution: 99% inactivation required 42.1 °C for 20 minutes or 44.6 °C for 5 minutes. The venom is released about 18 mm below the skin surface, a depth that heat cannot reach at these temperatures without exceeding the burn threshold (about 44 °C) at the skin surface. No data exist for S. verrucosa , the species present in the Indian Ocean. Pain relief is transient and returns once the limb leaves the water, a pattern better explained by counter-irritation than by venom inactivation.
Conclusion: HWI provides transient analgesia, but its supposed mechanism has never been demonstrated in patients, and for stonefish it cannot inactivate the venom at depth without risking a burn. Water temperature should be checked with a thermometer, kept below 45 °C and never left to the patient’s judgement. In hospital, loco-regional anaesthesia is a species-independent alternative without thermal risk when pain persists. A consensus among emergency physicians, poison control centres and first-aid organisations is needed to harmonise practice.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Keywords : hot water immersion, iatrogenic burn, stonefish, Synanceia verrucosa , venomous fish, envenomation
Bienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
L’accès au texte intégral de cet article nécessite un abonnement.
Déjà abonné à cette revue ?
