Prospective randomized comparison of short-access mother-baby cholangioscopy versus direct cholangioscopy with ultraslim gastroscopes - 19/09/13
Abstract |
Background |
Mother-baby technologies, the criterion standard for cholangioscopy, have several limitations. A novel, short-access, mother-baby (SAMBA) system may improve this technique. Direct cholangioscopy (DC) was recently developed as an alternative to mother-baby cholangioscopy.
Objective |
Comparison of success rates with SAMBA and DC.
Design |
Single-center, randomized, controlled trial.
Setting |
Academic tertiary-care referral center.
Patients |
Sixty patients with suspected cholangiopathies randomized to either SAMBA (n = 30) or DC (n = 30).
Intervention |
Cholangioscopy under deep sedation.
Main Outcome Measurements |
Technical success rate of diagnostic or therapeutic procedure.
Results |
A total of 24 and 21 diagnostic procedures were performed in the SAMBA and DC groups, respectively. There were no significant differences in the overall technical success rates between SAMBA (90.0%) and DC (86.7%) (P = 1.0). There was better correlation between the endoscopic prediction and histologic findings in DC (P = .013). Procedure times were shorter in DC (P < .03). In patients without significant stenoses, SAMBA allowed intrahepatic bile duct exploration in all cases, compared with 10.5% of cases in DC (P < .01). No differences regarding adverse event rates between the groups occurred (10.0% both groups).
Limitations |
Small sample size. Heterogeneous indications for cholangioscopy. DC requires advanced skills of the endoscopist. The study is not replicable.
Conclusion |
SAMBA and DC offer high technical success rates for diagnostic and therapeutic interventions. The advantages of DC consist of superior imaging, shorter total procedure time, and a wider working channel for adequate tissue sampling. SAMBA is better than DC with regard to intraductal stability and accessibility of the intrahepatic bile ducts.
Le texte complet de cet article est disponible en PDF.Abbreviations : CBD, DC, ERC, SAMBA
Plan
| DISCLOSURE: J. Pohl and C. Ell receive speakers' honoraria from Fujifilm, Inc. J. Pohl is a consultant for Karl Storz, Inc. No other financial relationships relevant to this publication were disclosed. |
Vol 78 - N° 4
P. 609-616 - octobre 2013 Retour au numéro
Article précédent
- The role of K-ras gene mutation analysis in EUS-guided FNA cytology specimens for the differential diagnosis of pancreatic solid masses: a meta-analysis of prospective studies
- Lorenzo Fuccio, Cesare Hassan, Liboria Laterza, Loredana Correale, Nico Pagano, Paolo Bocus, Carlo Fabbri, Antonella Maimone, Vincenzo Cennamo, Alessandro Repici, Guido Costamagna, Franco Bazzoli, Alberto Larghi
- Training in small-bowel capsule endoscopy: assessing and defining competency
- Elizabeth Rajan, Prasad G. Iyer, Amy S. Oxentenko, Darrell S. Pardi, Jeffrey A. Alexander, Todd H. Baron, David H. Bruining, Stephanie L. Hansel, Mark V. Larson, Joseph A. Murray, John DeBritto, Ross A. Dierkhising, Christopher J. Gostout
Bienvenue sur EM-consulte, la référence des professionnels de santé.
L’accès au texte intégral de cet article nécessite un abonnement.
Déjà abonné à cette revue ?