The definitions of most of the currently recognized neurodevelopmental disorders and the criteria used to identify them have seen important changes since their inclusion in diagnostic classification systems (see, for instance, how the definitions of specific learning disorders and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) have been revised in successive versions of DSM). As is the case with many other mental conditions, our understanding of neurodevelopmental disorders is continuously being updated in the light of new research findings. However, this has not been the case for nonverbal learning disability. More than 50 years since it was first described,¹ there is still no consensus on the merits of identifying it as a separate disorder or using a clear and acknowledged diagnostic label. Instead of trying to establish why nonverbal learning disability has yet to be included in the diagnostic manuals, this editorial examines why recognized criteria for the condition would improve research in this field and avoid the negative consequences of continuing to conduct research without adopting shared criteria.